The Deli @ Midway - West Salem | Classic American Sandwiches Fresh Salads in West Salem, WI

Overview

The Deli @ Midway - West Salem offers a genuine slice of American deli tradition right in the heart of West Salem, Wisconsin. Nestled along WI-16, this spot invites locals and visitors alike to savor classic deli sandwiches crafted with care and quality ingredients. Its menu focuses on hearty hoagies and iconic rye bread sandwiches, making it a go-to for anyone craving flavorful, satisfying comfort food.

Standouts include the Red Oak Rye selections—the Reuben, for example, blends tender corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and a touch of Thousand Island dressing on perfectly toasted rye bread. For those seeking a lighter yet equally delicious option, the Rachel swaps turkey for beef, maintaining that signature deli essence. Meanwhile, the Halfway Creek Hoagies bring variety and boldness with combinations like the New Yorker, packed with pastrami, corned beef, and turkey paired with fresh veggies and horsey mayo, or the Philly with its tender roast beef and sautéed green peppers and onions.

The atmosphere at The Deli @ Midway is welcoming and unpretentious—ideal for casual lunches or a quick, hearty meal. Its layout suits families, professionals, and anyone wanting a straightforward, satisfying dining experience without fuss. The daily specials, which pair half sandwiches with soup, add versatility for those in need of a fulfilling yet balanced meal.

Location-wise, The Deli is easily accessible and convenient for both West Salem residents and travelers passing through on WI-16. Whether you’re stopping by to grab a classic deli sandwich or spending some time enjoying a leisurely lunch, the experience hinges on fresh ingredients, well-balanced flavors, and the timeless appeal of American deli fare.

Overall, The Deli @ Midway - West Salem stands out as a dependable and inviting option for deli lovers. It balances tradition with an array of sandwich choices that cater to a broad audience, without sacrificing quality or comfort. For anyone seeking authentic American deli delights in a friendly, laid-back setting, this spot delivers with consistency and heart.

Menu Highlights

See Full Menu

Amenities & Services

Popular for

Lunch

Solo dining

Offerings

Comfort food

Quick bite

Atmosphere

Casual

Cosy

What Customers Say

Jennifer Mwah

Mar 7,2026

5/5

We had their sandwiches and soups catered for lunch and it was delicious! It so happen to rain today and I gor their tomato basil soup which was the best for the temperature. The bread for their sandwiches are so soft, the ingredients are fresh and the pickles are SOO GOOD! I'm so glad we got the chance to try them. I will have to personally come back to try their other sandwhiches and soups. Thank you for catering for us!

Sue Ann K

Mar 7,2026

5/5

Qaint small town deli. unique food and tastes fantastic, Favorite, Rachel sandwich without the sauerkraut and thousand Island on rye bread

Meaghan

Mar 7,2026

4/5

To be completely honest I'm not a huge fan of the bread they use, (the only reason for the one star deduction)but that's not why I'm reviewing. I am currently stupidly sick and literally the only thing that's brought me a moment of comfort, and that I can even eat, is the French Onion Soup. I've been all over the country, I'm from the North East, from really food dense areas. And Midway Deli has the best French onion soup I've ever had. The flavor is top notch, well seasoned. It's absolutely perfect, and will probably be my go-to sick soup this whole winter. Hats off to the chef for that one! The service is always really good too, they are kind and super welcoming when you step in.

Melissa Benzing

Mar 7,2026

5/5

The absolute best. The food is exactly what we love from Midway, always fresh and so tasty. The owner was so kind and played with my toddler son with the toys they had there at the restaurant while we ate. We felt so welcomed in a way we haven’t experienced elsewhere. This is a true gem.

Dan Sampson

Mar 7,2026

5/5

This sandwich shop is amazing. The hoagie is amazing. Soft and fluffy yet held up well to the toppings. They have a great choice of sandwiches. The owner is very friendly and did a great job of making sure we got what we wanted on our sandwiches. They have ice cream also which is an added bonus

Jesus351w

Mar 7,2026

4/5

Not bad, sandwich was good but definitely could have used more meat. Talk about subs loaded with meat go to Sparta. Would I go here again? Maybe if they improved more meat to sandwich and a few bread options would be nice.

Barbara Stelloh

Mar 7,2026

5/5

Midway Deli has the best deli sandwiches I've ever had! I've never been disappointed. The bread is amazing, the ingredients are quality and fresh, the service is always thorough and attentive, there are food and drink options for the whole family. West Salem is lucky to have this local gem!

Jacob Stetzer

Mar 7,2026

5/5

Im not going to lie, it took a while to get our sandwiches, but man were they worth the wait!

Leave a Review

Top Picks for You

The Deli @ Midway - West Salem - in West Salem, Wisconsin, USA

Overview

Menu Highlights

Amenities & Services

What Customers Say

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

More in West Salem, Wisconsin, USA